Dice Roller or Monster Catcher?

This discussion is about which one is better, The Dice Roller or The Monster Catcher

My Opinion
Lots of people say to me would you rather roll the dice instead I always say
Actually YES, I'd RATHER have the feeling of doing something and getting ALMOST THERE that is how you become a dertimined person, such as setting goals, but with this catching thing... theres no point because you know you'll get it... and doing it like 8 times to gain one level, thats madness, atleast for rolling well, I think its ALOT shorter then doing this and theres also a bug which is SOOO anoying but I know they'll remove it (I BLOODY HOPE).

Bottom Line...
Please AE stick to what you've always done and thats your reputation and tradition. A wonderful example Ray Ban. Its a new sunglasses makers where they make back in the 40's styles and 60's like John Lennon's, and although they do make modern day ones, they make very few just like MQ's Ghost Catcher, and I've got the old style versions and im so glad to have one thinking about the times that rockstars and famous other people using this and NOW the tradition and reputation of this STYLE STILL LIVES. even though you have good ideas but still, If you see people not liking them PLEASE do not continue it will just draw away players, such as me.

Your Thoughts?